2023 Reader Recipe Contest - Spooky

Never let it be said that Rae Hruby let a holiday pass without cooking something specific to the occasion.

St. Patrick’s Day, for example, is an occasion to set up a fruit tray arranged like a rainbow; red, white, and blue themes rule the table on Independence Day. But on Halloween: Bring out the Feetloaf.

Hruby’s horror-movie-prop-turned-main-course took top honors in Ohio Cooperative Living’s annual Reader Recipe Contest; this year’s theme was “Spooky,” and Feetloaf certainly fit the bill, earning her an Ohio-made KitchenAid stand mixer.

Rae Hruby and family

Rae Hruby and family

Cynthia Boles

“I’ve just always done my themed foods,” says Hruby, who lives in Grafton, where she and her husband, Paul, are members of Wellington-based Lorain-Medina Rural Electric Cooperative. “I took four years of foods classes in high school, and I’ve always enjoyed doing creative things with food.”

Part of that passion for creative cuisine has been inspired by her love of cooking with and for kids — her own and any others who happen to stop by the house. She and Paul have a grown daughter, Lauren, and a son, Dmitry, 15, so she’s been cooking for kids for quite a while now. 

“We always had neighbor kids who came over to go trick-or-treating, and I always tried to make sure they had some real food before they went out,” she says. 

Meatloaf, she says, was a natural because of its versatility to feed a few or a group. And of course, she couldn’t make just a plain old loaf.

“You know, it’s basically just a slab of meat, but with the ketchup, it doesn’t take much imagination to create a body part, and a foot was just fun,” she says. “That just happened to be what I was working with at the time — it could have been spaghetti worms, or really any number of things.”

Cynthia Boles of Lithopolis, a member of Lancaster-based South Central Power Company, took runner-up honors in this year’s contest with her Batty Spinach Balls.

“It’s a recipe that’s been in the family forever,” Boles says. “It’s one of the few vegetable dishes that we never had any trouble getting the kids to eat. We serve it all the time, though we don’t dress it up for Halloween when it’s out of season.”

She says her mother, Rose, first came up with the original recipe, but she’s adapted it for a busy lifestyle by making it with boxed stuffing mix, and made it a spooky Halloween favorite with the simple addition of blue tortilla chips for bat wings. Her sons, Jacob, now 23, and Nathan, 22, and her husband, Bill, still gobble them up whenever she makes them.

The dish is plenty versatile as well. Boles serves the spinach balls as either an appetizer or a side dish, and the recipe is adaptable to account for spice preferences. “We usually make two batches: one hot and one not,” she says. “Me, I like a little kick.”

Recipe submitted by Rae Hruby · Lorain-Medina Rural Electric Cooperative member

Yield
12 Servings
Preparation time
30 minutes
Cooking time
1 hour, 20 minutes
Total time
1 hour, 50 minutes
Ingredients
1 small onion
3 pounds your favorite meatloaf mix (I use lean ground beef only)
1 package dry French onion soup mix
1⁄2 cup ketchup (reserve additional for serving on the side)
2 eggs
1 cup oatmeal or breadcrumbs
  salt and pepper to taste
Instructions
Rae Hruby

Slice one round of onion for the ankle bone and a few small slivers for toenails, then finely chop the rest. Mix all ingredients except the reserved onion and ketchup together until well incorporated.

Form into something resembling a foot. Spoon a bit of the extra ketchup at the top and embellish with an onion ankle bone and onion toenails.

Preheat oven to 350 F. Bake in a shallow baking dish with foil tented over, approximately 1 hour; remove foil and complete cooking for approximately 20 minutes.

Recipe submitted by Cynthia Boles · South Central Power Company member

Yield
12 Servings
Preparation time
20 minutes
Cooking time
20 minutes
Total time
40 minutes
Ingredients
1 package frozen spinach (9-10 ounces)
2 eggs
1⁄3 cup vegetable oil
1⁄2 cup Parmesan cheese
1 box Stove Top stuffing (your choice of flavor)
1⁄2 teaspoon garlic salt
1 medium onion (diced)
  hot pepper seeds to taste
  pimentos or red bell pepper chips for decorating
  tortilla chips for garnish
Instructions
Cynthia Boles

Cook spinach according to package instructions and drain well. Cool. Add ingredients (spinach through hot pepper seeds) to large bowl and mix well. Form mixture into 1-inch balls. Place on baking sheet sprayed with nonstick coating.

Bake at 350 F for 10 minutes. Turn balls over and bake for an additional 10 minutes. After spinach balls are baked, press in pimentos or red bell pepper chips for eyes. On the back of the spinach ball, press in triangular tortilla chips for wings. Serve hot.